Caleb, you mentioned trying something lighter. Have you considered playing or running Monster of the Week or Monsterheart? They very buffy/supernatural centered games set in high schools. While they have some combat they're very much a narrative game, where people riff of one another, sort of in the vein if the Quiet Year. The guy who made quiet year made Monsterheart, which is really a hack of apocalypse world, much like monster of the