Ideas, will check for time codes later tonight:
Locke playing the priest of Pelor (like a televangelist) to (I think) convince what's his name to take the boat 1:45ish-1:55:30ish (meat of the bit starts at about 1:48:30/1:51) NWC 28 7/12/2010 (In reviewing this scene, I forgot how great Ross and Dan did as well)
The chaos in planning the destruction of the phylactery in the town hall
(Not sure about this one) I seem to recall something amusing regarding convincing the water spirit and fire spirit to wed. Maybe it was just their impersonation of the water spirit.
I think this was from the main podcast (it could be from another since I was checking out several at the time), sometime two years ago or so you each made up RPG scenarios based on 4-5 elements that the other came up with
Really short segment, but from the Santa Claus MaOCT, the bit where one of the players was flustered and swore, not being sure what to say and you took that as in game dialogue
Meeting up of the 1980s LoEG 10:00-15:00-ish 5/15/2010
Tom's rant as a velociraptor in the Wushu dodgeball game (about how humiliating it was to pretend to be unable to open a door)
The April Fools game for CoC (maybe can just do the whole thing) Call of Cthulhu - Wrath of Cthulhu Game 73 4/1/2009
Cody talking to the lunch ladies in the Arcadia Signal game
The fight in the hotel in the Cyberpunk game
Something from Tom's crazy character in the GURPS yakuza game (I don't remember much about the scene, but I think there was one where he took a guy's head and paraded around with it, or something of the like)
The gremlin fight in the 1980s LoEG game 17:00-33:30-ish problem finished, some distractions, then plan to wrap up from 35-39 5/15/2010
The "Is that a tree on that badge encounter" in the Candle Cove game
Talking about the skinheads/shooting on the roof/jumping on segways/the cinnaman/whatever else in the Night Cop game
There was another one with one of Tom's characters I can't remember
New World Gaiden 2: Talking to the spider "I'm allergic to health potions" 3:28:30-3:37-ish 10/7/2010
*All dates are the dates posted (from iTunes)
So that's what's off the top of my head, I'll look for more tonight when I go in depth for time codes.