Playing a CthulhuTech game. Important note here: the players know it's going to be massively combat heavy. Players are playing Tagers, which are basically monsters, so all the fights are big monster vs monster brawls with claws and magic beams and shit. Awesome shit.
Middle of the big fight, one of the characters gets attacked while paralyzed so I inform him that, since he can't move from that spot he can't use his Dodge Skill, but he can counter the attack by using his Fighting Skill.
The dude looked down at his sheet, kind of glanced around without meeting anyone's eyes, and said "I didn't take Fighting".
His character got hit so hard that the character's head came off.